As civil society organisations we are profoundly disturbed by the nature, content and potential impact of the homophobic stance taken by Jerry Matjila, South Africa's representative at the United Nations Human Rights Council in Geneva, on the 16th of June 2010. This stance is the latest in a string of problematic actions by South African representatives in international forums such as the UN.

In a discussion on a report by the Special Rappoteur on Racism, Matjila said that to protect gay people, "demeans the legitimate plight of the victims of racism".

It is clear that this sentiment is contrary to the country’s Constitution which states:

"The state may not unfairly discriminate directly or indirectly against anyone on one or more grounds, including race, gender, sex, pregnancy, marital status, ethnic or social origin, colour, sexual orientation, age, disability, religion, conscience, belief, culture, language and birth."

Matjila’s stance is insensitive to the persecution of LGBTI (lesbians, gays, bisexual, transgender and intersex) people that seems to be on the increase in several countries in the continent including increasing hate crimes and violence against LGBTIs in South Africa itself. Matjila’s stance is a tacit endorsement of all this persecution and hate crimes.

We also reject the assertion that upholding equality and dignity for LGBTIs in any way detracts from or “demeans” other plights. To the contrary, we acknowledge that there are multiple and intersecting identities and that the struggles against poverty, racism and all forms of discrimination are intimately connected, that since LGBTI are a subset of the population – millions of whom have been and continue to be victims of racism and racial oppression as well as socio-economic injustices - there will never be full equality until poverty, inequality and racism are effectively and structurally addressed.

We call on the government to immediately and permanently distance themselves from the unconstitutional comments of Matjila, and to withdraw the statement as that representing South Africa’s official position to the UN Human Rights Committee. To this effect, we will send an open letter to President Zuma and the Minister of International Cooperation, Ms Maite Nkoana Mashabane. Furthermore, following the positive statement by President Zuma condemning the conviction and imprisonment of a Malawian gay couple under discriminatory laws in Malawi, we call on the ruling party and government to consistently and openly speak out and act against homophobia and all forms of oppression. To do so is not a luxury but an absolute necessity as government is required to promote, respect and advance the rights in our Constitution.
We commit ourselves to mobilise the LGBTI community, the rest of civil society and progressive social forces to take public action to challenge and condemn government’s consistent homophobic sentiments at the UN and in other international fora. We will also use such public action to call on government to ensure that South Africa promotes a progressive agenda when it comes to the removal of sexual orientation discrimination in our region, continent and world. Without this, our Constitution and international standing is not worth the paper it is written on.

Good Hope MCC and other Civil Society Organisations in South Africa are signatories of this statement.